Pilgrim Reaper
DARK

Pilgrim Reaper

  • ATK:
  • -1

  • DEF:
  • -1

  • View:
  • 4950




2 Level 6 monsters Gains 200 ATK/DEF for each DARK monster in the GYs. You can detach 1 material from this card; each player sends the top 5 cards from their Deck to the GY (or their entire Deck, if less than 5). You can only use this effect of "Pilgrim Reaper" once per turn.




 
 
AI Power Analysis
Combo enablerConfidence: MediumEvaluated Oct 1, 2026
61± 6/ 100
Power Score
Intrinsic 59
Deck 60

Pilgrim Reaper — Power Evaluation

Final Score: 61 ± 6 · Confidence: Medium

  • Intrinsic: 59 · Deck: 60 · Meta: provisional
  • Primary role: Combo enabler · Secondary: Material body

Why it scores here

Pilgrim Reaper earns its score as a contextual GY accelerator: its once-per-turn mill of 5 cards fuels Tearlaments GY fusions, Lightsworn pile engines, and Fiendsmith chains far more than it typically benefits an opponent, which is why it achieves 100% inclusion in those archetypes. The broad footprint across 48 distinct archetype homes confirms genuine deck-building flexibility, and guides listing it as a Staple in 60-card GY-pile strategies corroborate that real role. The base ATK/DEF of zero did NOT drive any points; the ATK scaling is a secondary upside of the mill, not a power source, and requiring 2 Level 6 materials keeps accessibility from scoring higher despite the wide usage.

Axis scores

Axis Score Evidence
Accessibility 55 Requires exactly 2 Level 6 monsters as XYZ material — achievable via Keldo or Mudora (both Level 6 Ishizu package cards that co-occur in 79–82% of sampled decks) or other Level 6 lines, but not a guaranteed turn-one play without setup (inferred from deck co-occurrence).
Combo & Conversion 60 In Tearlaments (35% of 400 sampled decks combined) and Lightsworn, milling 5 cards per turn triggers GY fusion chains and recursion effects; guides explicitly place it in a 'Mộ Xum Xuê' (filled GY) section alongside Tearlaments and Fiendsmith engine pieces (observed from guides/deck evidence).
Resource Economy 58 Symmetric 5-card mill generates asymmetric card advantage in GY-centric strategies where each sent card can trigger an effect, whereas the opponent's 5 milled cards are often inert; listed as Staple in a 60-card Cubic Tearlaments Fiendsmith guide confirming economic value (observed).
Effect & Interaction 30 Card text provides no disruption, negation, or targeted removal; the only opponent-interactive element is incidentally milling their key cards, which is indirect and unreliable (verified from card text).
Material Utility 55 Rank 6 DARK Zombie XYZ can function as material for follow-up plays after its own material is detached; DARK attribute aligns with partner cards like Fiendsmith and Tearlaments; zero combo appearances means material utility is text-inferred only (inferred).
Resilience & Flexibility 45 Spans 48 distinct archetype homes showing strong cross-deck flexibility, but carries no self-protection and is fully answered by a single Ash Blossom or boardwipe; once-per-turn clause limits recovery burst (observed deck breadth, inferred vulnerability).
Deck-Building Efficiency 50 398 of 400 decks run exactly 1 copy indicating minimal slot cost, but the Level 6 XYZ material requirement is a genuine deckbuilding constraint that not every strategy can satisfy cleanly (observed).

Calculation

Weight profile: 0.7 Combo enabler + 0.3 Material body. Intrinsic ≈ 59, Deck ≈ 60, Meta = provisional. Modifiers: broad_splash (2); symmetric_mill_risk (-1). Final formula: 0.40*Intrinsic + 0.60*Deck

Strengths

  • Provides reliable GY acceleration via 5-card mill per turn, fueling DARK/GY-centric strategies disproportionately over the opponent
  • Broadly splashable across 48+ archetype homes (Tearlaments, Fiendsmith, Lightsworn, Shaddoll, Horus, Kashtira, Darklord)
  • Generic Rank 6 material requirement fits naturally into many engine configurations without archetype-specific support
  • Symmetric mill disproportionately favors the controller in GY-centric decks where more GY cards translate to more effects

Weaknesses

  • No built-in protection or disruption — removed easily on the opponent's turn
  • Symmetric mill can backfire in GY-centric mirrors or against opponents who also benefit from GY setup
  • Requires two Level 6 monsters to XYZ summon — not always achievable from hand alone without dedicated setup
  • Base ATK/DEF is effectively zero; battle value depends entirely on prior GY accumulation

Counters / choke points

  • Ash Blossom & Joyous Spring negates the mill effect (sends cards from Deck to GY)
  • Dimensional Shifter and Macro Cosmos banish all GY-bound cards, completely nullifying the mill's value
  • Nibiru the Primal Being can punish multi-Normal Summon setups often needed to reach Level 6 materials
  • Droll & Lock Bird stops follow-up searches after the mill activates in the same turn

Best use

Rank 6 GY accelerator that fuels fusion and recursion chains in DARK-heavy strategies. Decks: Tearlaments, Lightsworn, Fiendsmith, Shaddoll, Horus. Suggested copies: 1.

Evidence & gaps

  • Verified: Requires exactly 2 Level 6 monsters as XYZ material (card text); Gains 200 ATK/DEF per DARK monster in either GY (card text); Mill effect sends exactly 5 cards (or entire Deck if fewer) from each player's Deck to GY (card text); Mill effect is Once Per Turn (card text); Appears in 400 of 400 sampled decks in the main deck (deck evidence); Run at exactly 1 copy in 398 of 400 decks (deck evidence); Legal in TCG, OCG, and MasterDuel formats (card formats)
  • Observed: Present in 48 distinct archetype homes across the 400 sampled decks (deck evidence); 100% inclusion rate in Tearlaments and Lightsworn archetypes per usage statistics (usage statistics); Listed as Staple in a 60-card Cubic Tearlaments Fiendsmith guide (guides evidence); Listed alongside GY-fill cards in a Lightsworn FTK guide section named 'Mộ Xum Xuê' (guides evidence); Top co-occurrence partners are core Tearlaments, Fiendsmith, and Ishizu cards at 78–87% co-presence (deck evidence)
  • Inferred: Symmetric mill benefits GY-centric controller more than a typical opponent, creating net asymmetric advantage in DARK strategies; Level 6 material requirement is met via Keldo and Mudora (Ishizu engine Level 6 cards) present in 79–82% of same decks; Rank 6 DARK Zombie body can serve as material for follow-up XYZ or DARK-supported plays after its own material is detached
  • Data gaps: No combo data supplied — combo conversion and material utility are text-only inferences No banlist token — assumed unlimited (3 copies) in all formats No metagame tier data available — meta power is provisional/null











https://metaduelist.com/
Top