DARK
Pilgrim Reaper
ATK:
-1
DEF:
-1
View:
4950
2 Level 6 monsters Gains 200 ATK/DEF for each DARK monster in the GYs. You can detach 1 material from this card; each player sends the top 5 cards from their Deck to the GY (or their entire Deck, if less than 5). You can only use this effect of "Pilgrim Reaper" once per turn.
Pilgrim Reaper — Power Evaluation
Final Score: 61 ± 6 · Confidence: Medium
- Intrinsic: 59 · Deck: 60 · Meta: provisional
- Primary role: Combo enabler · Secondary: Material body
Why it scores here
Pilgrim Reaper earns its score as a contextual GY accelerator: its once-per-turn mill of 5 cards fuels Tearlaments GY fusions, Lightsworn pile engines, and Fiendsmith chains far more than it typically benefits an opponent, which is why it achieves 100% inclusion in those archetypes. The broad footprint across 48 distinct archetype homes confirms genuine deck-building flexibility, and guides listing it as a Staple in 60-card GY-pile strategies corroborate that real role. The base ATK/DEF of zero did NOT drive any points; the ATK scaling is a secondary upside of the mill, not a power source, and requiring 2 Level 6 materials keeps accessibility from scoring higher despite the wide usage.
Axis scores
| Axis | Score | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Accessibility | 55 | Requires exactly 2 Level 6 monsters as XYZ material — achievable via Keldo or Mudora (both Level 6 Ishizu package cards that co-occur in 79–82% of sampled decks) or other Level 6 lines, but not a guaranteed turn-one play without setup (inferred from deck co-occurrence). |
| Combo & Conversion | 60 | In Tearlaments (35% of 400 sampled decks combined) and Lightsworn, milling 5 cards per turn triggers GY fusion chains and recursion effects; guides explicitly place it in a 'Mộ Xum Xuê' (filled GY) section alongside Tearlaments and Fiendsmith engine pieces (observed from guides/deck evidence). |
| Resource Economy | 58 | Symmetric 5-card mill generates asymmetric card advantage in GY-centric strategies where each sent card can trigger an effect, whereas the opponent's 5 milled cards are often inert; listed as Staple in a 60-card Cubic Tearlaments Fiendsmith guide confirming economic value (observed). |
| Effect & Interaction | 30 | Card text provides no disruption, negation, or targeted removal; the only opponent-interactive element is incidentally milling their key cards, which is indirect and unreliable (verified from card text). |
| Material Utility | 55 | Rank 6 DARK Zombie XYZ can function as material for follow-up plays after its own material is detached; DARK attribute aligns with partner cards like Fiendsmith and Tearlaments; zero combo appearances means material utility is text-inferred only (inferred). |
| Resilience & Flexibility | 45 | Spans 48 distinct archetype homes showing strong cross-deck flexibility, but carries no self-protection and is fully answered by a single Ash Blossom or boardwipe; once-per-turn clause limits recovery burst (observed deck breadth, inferred vulnerability). |
| Deck-Building Efficiency | 50 | 398 of 400 decks run exactly 1 copy indicating minimal slot cost, but the Level 6 XYZ material requirement is a genuine deckbuilding constraint that not every strategy can satisfy cleanly (observed). |
Calculation
Weight profile: 0.7 Combo enabler + 0.3 Material body. Intrinsic ≈ 59, Deck ≈ 60, Meta = provisional. Modifiers: broad_splash (2); symmetric_mill_risk (-1). Final formula: 0.40*Intrinsic + 0.60*Deck
Strengths
- Provides reliable GY acceleration via 5-card mill per turn, fueling DARK/GY-centric strategies disproportionately over the opponent
- Broadly splashable across 48+ archetype homes (Tearlaments, Fiendsmith, Lightsworn, Shaddoll, Horus, Kashtira, Darklord)
- Generic Rank 6 material requirement fits naturally into many engine configurations without archetype-specific support
- Symmetric mill disproportionately favors the controller in GY-centric decks where more GY cards translate to more effects
Weaknesses
- No built-in protection or disruption — removed easily on the opponent's turn
- Symmetric mill can backfire in GY-centric mirrors or against opponents who also benefit from GY setup
- Requires two Level 6 monsters to XYZ summon — not always achievable from hand alone without dedicated setup
- Base ATK/DEF is effectively zero; battle value depends entirely on prior GY accumulation
Counters / choke points
- Ash Blossom & Joyous Spring negates the mill effect (sends cards from Deck to GY)
- Dimensional Shifter and Macro Cosmos banish all GY-bound cards, completely nullifying the mill's value
- Nibiru the Primal Being can punish multi-Normal Summon setups often needed to reach Level 6 materials
- Droll & Lock Bird stops follow-up searches after the mill activates in the same turn
Best use
Rank 6 GY accelerator that fuels fusion and recursion chains in DARK-heavy strategies. Decks: Tearlaments, Lightsworn, Fiendsmith, Shaddoll, Horus. Suggested copies: 1.
Evidence & gaps
- Verified: Requires exactly 2 Level 6 monsters as XYZ material (card text); Gains 200 ATK/DEF per DARK monster in either GY (card text); Mill effect sends exactly 5 cards (or entire Deck if fewer) from each player's Deck to GY (card text); Mill effect is Once Per Turn (card text); Appears in 400 of 400 sampled decks in the main deck (deck evidence); Run at exactly 1 copy in 398 of 400 decks (deck evidence); Legal in TCG, OCG, and MasterDuel formats (card formats)
- Observed: Present in 48 distinct archetype homes across the 400 sampled decks (deck evidence); 100% inclusion rate in Tearlaments and Lightsworn archetypes per usage statistics (usage statistics); Listed as Staple in a 60-card Cubic Tearlaments Fiendsmith guide (guides evidence); Listed alongside GY-fill cards in a Lightsworn FTK guide section named 'Mộ Xum Xuê' (guides evidence); Top co-occurrence partners are core Tearlaments, Fiendsmith, and Ishizu cards at 78–87% co-presence (deck evidence)
- Inferred: Symmetric mill benefits GY-centric controller more than a typical opponent, creating net asymmetric advantage in DARK strategies; Level 6 material requirement is met via Keldo and Mudora (Ishizu engine Level 6 cards) present in 79–82% of same decks; Rank 6 DARK Zombie body can serve as material for follow-up XYZ or DARK-supported plays after its own material is detached
- Data gaps: No combo data supplied — combo conversion and material utility are text-only inferences No banlist token — assumed unlimited (3 copies) in all formats No metagame tier data available — meta power is provisional/null






